An Observation of
Ten Resisters Speaking Truth to Power
On December 27 and 28,
2016, radical Christian pacifists from the Atlantic and Southern Life
Communities gathered for a Faith and Resistance Retreat at St. Stephen and the
Incarnation Episcopal Church in Washington, D.C. Each year there is a gathering to commemorate
the Feast of the Holy Innocents, and to speak out about the massacre of
children from the past and the present. This retreat honored Dan Berrigan, SJ,
who died on April 30, 2016, a friend and mentor to so many peacemakers.
A part of the retreat
is an early-morning pilgrimage to the Pentagon, which happened at 7 AM on
December 28. The pilgrims carried life-size cardboard cut-outs of Dan,
made by the Ithaca Catholic Worker, and a banner with the statement of
the Catonsville Nine: “The violence stops here, the death stops here, the
suppression of truth stops here, this war stops here." Sixteen of the
participants gathered on a sidewalk heading to the Pentagon, while others went
into the pen set up to hold protesters. All involved sang “The Vine and
Fig Tree.” The sixteen were arrested, and charged with a failure to obey
a lawful order. The U.S. Attorney at the Pentagon, Paul Embroski, does not
prosecute first-time offenders, so just ten of the resisters went on trial on
March 2, 2017 in U.S. District Court in Alexandria, VA.
The prosecutor hoped the
defendants would plead guilty. Instead, after some dialogue, the
defendants came to an agreement to plead no contest, to stipulate to the facts,
thus negating a need for a police witness, and to make a pre-trial motion for
dismissal. Magistrate Judge Ivan Davis would preside at trial.
In 2013, six of us were
arrested at the Central Intelligence Agency after delivering a letter, from the
National Campaign for Nonviolent Resistance condemning killer drone strikes, to
a CIA representative. Five of us then appeared before Davis for
trial. A police witness was given a copy of the letter, and
he corroborated the fact that it was delivered to a representative of the
CIA. However, Davis would not allow us to enter the letter into evidence.
What gives? Of course we were convicted, and then Davis placed us on a
year’s probation. He did not impress me as a jurist.
The next time I
observed Judge Davis was at a trial of a group of activists arrested at the
Pentagon on September 26, 2016. This action was the culmination of a
World Beyond War conference the weekend before. His courtroom resolve in
that case was as unimpressive as it was in the CIA trial.
The Holy Innocents Ten gathered
in Davis’s courtroom, and for the third time I got a chance to observe this
magistrate judge. In a pre-trial hearing, defendant Carmen Trotta of the
New York Catholic Worker presented his motion for dismissal. He implored
the judge to take action against the U.S. government for its illegal
confinement of prisoners at Guantanamo and the use of torture. He pointed
out that President
Obama signed into law the indefinite
detention bill embedded in
the 2012 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). In other words, the
due process clause of the Bill of Rights is irrelevant. Such a law is
unconstitutional, and the judge has a responsibility to protect the Bill
of Rights. Davis was not swayed by the argument, indicating the defendant
did not cite any court cases for him to consider. So the motion was denied.
After
the court proceedings were completed, Carmen was still looking for a way to
convince a legal authority that indefinite detention was legally
horrendous. He pointed out that the indefinite detention provision is
still contained in the 2017 NDAA.
Another pre-trial argument was
made by defendant Steve Woolford. He explained that the defendants hoped
to enter nolo contendre pleas. Davis asked why. Steve explained they were
not contesting the elements of the police report. The prosecutor then
read a statement of facts which would not be contested. However, Davis did not
allow a no contest plea, “as it is not in the best interest of the public.” This
made no sense to me. After some discussion, the defendants entered not
guilty pleas.
The
prosecutor’s case was the statement of facts. He emphasized they were arrested
for the obstruction of access, not for their speech. The defendants stipulated
to the facts presented by Embroski. The judge than found them
guilty. Each defendant then made a statement before sentencing.
Steve Baggarly of the Norfolk
Catholic Worker argued that the U.S. government war making in Yemen was
illegal. He provided the gruesome details of a U.S. attack there which
killed many non-combatants, including children.
The judge urged the defendants
to limit their statements for the purpose of judicial economy. I
suspected that the defendants would not let this warning inhibit their right to
speak.
Kathy Boylan of the Dorothy Day
Catholic Worker in D.C., which has organized a Monday morning vigil at the
Pentagon for decades, explained that the protesters bring with them the God of
Love. The government has gone to war many times based on lies--from the
Gulf of Tonkin to the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The government
violates with consistency the constitution. However, it is the protesters
who are brought to trial.
Beth Brockman from North
Carolina told the judge about the Dan Berrigan cut-outs. She then
informed the court that at the retreat the poem “Prayer For The Morning
Headlines” by Daniel Berrigan was read. On the Metro, she witnessed a
fourteen-year-old being arrested by four police officers. She and others
stayed to observe. Why do we act? For the
children.
Carol Gilbert, O.P.,
a Dominican, just celebrated her fiftieth anniversary. She said forty of
those years were spent challenging the military-industrial complex, and
reminded the judge of the court’s importance. Judges can obviously be a
bulwark against government misconduct, but so few rarely rise to the
challenge.
Bill Ofenloch from New York spoke
about the Holy Innocents and the need to stop the violence against the
children. He quoted from Dan Berrigan that the wealth of the resources
was provided by God. But war is the great disrupter. He asked the
judge to consider giving the defendants community service.
Ardeth Platter, O.P. said she has been a
Dominican sister for 63 years, and will soon complete her 81st year. She
did not think she has many more years left to work for justice, civil rights,
the farmworkers and women and against homophobia. She has been living for
years near Freddie Gray’s neighborhood. There is violence in Baltimore,
as well as in Sudan. It must all be stopped. Finally, she brought
to the judge’s attention the book and film COMMAND AND CONTROL, which is about
the madness of nuclear arms.
Janice
Sevre-Duszynska grew up in a Polish neighborhood in Milwaukee. Her Uncle
Hank fought in the Battle of the Bulge and came home with PTSD. He had
the job of picking up body parts from the battlefield. As an ESOL
teacher, she encountered students from 65 countries, including many where war
was ongoing. She sees the devastation in Baltimore, and wonders why funding is
unavailable to save the city. Janice was greatly offended by Donald Trump
wanting to increase the military budget by $54 billion. She had to say no
more war at the Pentagon.
Bill
Frankel-Streit of the Little Flower Catholic Worker in Louisa, VA, indicated
the court was getting a picture of the passion of these defendants. They
actually could say so much more. As a father he has the responsibility of
taking care of his six children, three of whom are adults. This
responsibility extends out to protect other children. He indicated Dan
Berrigan said no grand scheme is worth the taking of one life.
Carmen suggested
that the defendants should not be punished, but instead should be thanked.
Woolford reminded
the court of the dangers of depleted uranium, a very dangerous toxin, which
U.S. forces are using in Syria. He recognized the diligence of the judge, but
urged him to look at this case in a different light. Growing up in
Massachusetts, he was taught in school that the Boston Tea Party was an
honorable action. And of course, civil rights icon Martin Luther King,
despite the rightness of his cause. was sent to jail. The Holy Innocents
group did not threaten anyone at the Pentagon. An appropriate sentence
would be community service and time served.
Judge Davis
appreciated the suggestions, but indicated it is his responsibility to prevent
these violations from happening again. Community service is not a viable option
and is ineffective as a deterrent. The defendants were ordered to pay
$200 plus court costs, and were given 120 days to pay.
Carmen apologized
for the vigor he used in arguing to have the case dismissed. Davis said
there is no need to apologize, as he is from the streets.
According to Baggarly, “After leaving the courtroom, the assistant prosecutor,
who had been nodding in agreement during much of our time speaking, thanked us
very much for the education.” Embroski also indicated he would try to
return the Dan Berrigan cut-outs and the banner which the police
confiscated. Unfortunately, the defendants did not file a Motion to
Preserve the Evidence. This would have forced the police to bring the
banner and the cut-outs into court. It would have been a sight to see Dan
Berrigan back in a courtroom.
The eloquence of
the defendants’ sentencing statements seemed to have an effect on Davis. I
sensed that he was touched by the sincerity of the statements. And for
sure, there was a lot of speaking truth to power in a courtroom in Alexandria,
VA, on March 2, 2017..
Max Obuszewski, a
Baltimore peace and justice advocate, can be reached at mobuszewski at Verizon
dot net or 410-323-1607.
Donations can be sent
to the Baltimore Nonviolence Center, 325 E. 25th St., Baltimore, MD
21218. Ph: 410-323-1607; Email: mobuszewski [at] verizon.net. Go to http://baltimorenonviolencecenter.blogspot.com/
"The master class
has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles.
The master class has had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject
class has had nothing to gain and everything to lose--especially their lives."
Eugene Victor Debs
No comments:
Post a Comment