A prisoner. (photo: Getty Images)
With
No Insanity Defense, Seriously Ill People End Up in Prison
By Natalie Jacewicz, NPR
06 August 16
In light of John Hinckley Jr.'s release from a psychiatric
hospital 35 years after attempting to assassinate President Ronald Reagan,
Shots is exploring the use of the not guilty by reason of insanity plea. We're
talking with legal and medical professionals about how the plea works, and how
it doesn't work. In this fourth of a four-part series, we look at what happens
to defendants when a state has no insanity defense.
n
the evening of March 8, 2016, 30-year-old Kyle Odom was arrested in Washington, D.C.,
for throwing objects over the White House fence. He'd traveled from Idaho,
where authorities suspected him of shooting and wounding Idaho pastor Tim
Remington in a church parking lot days earlier.
Shortly
after his arrest, an Idaho television station released a 30-page manifesto believed
to have been sent by Odom. In the letter, the writer claims his life was ruined by
"an intelligent species of amphibian-humanoid from Mars" using humans
as sex slaves. The manifesto included drawings of the aliens and a claim that
President Obama and Remington were aware of or involved in the Martians' plot.
Odom
was extradited to Idaho, and in early July, mediation of his case began before
a judge rather than going to trial before a jury. Forgoing a trial is typical
for cases in Idaho involving mental illness, says August Cahill, a recently
retired chief deputy of the Ada County Public Defender's Office in Boise,
Idaho. The state is one of four, along with Montana, Utah and Kansas, with no
insanity defense. The cases "don't go to trial because ultimately, what
are you going to say to the jury?" asks Cahill. "You'd say, 'Yes, my
client killed this person....' You don't have a defense."
Because
Idaho has no insanity defense, defendants with mental illness typically plead
guilty to lesser charges and rely on judges to take mental health into account
at sentencing. Some lawyers and psychiatrists say this doesn't provide enough
protection against the death penalty or long incarceration. As professor Aliza Cover of the University of Idaho Law
School explains, "In Idaho, you have the unusual circumstance that someone
who couldn't even be convicted in another state could be executed."
The
prosecutor in Odom's case, deputy prosecuting attorney Jed Whitaker, says he
can't discuss the ongoing mediation, but that the state does offer protections
for the mentally ill. "A mental health court is a way that you can
prosecute and help people who have a mental illness without necessarily sending
them to prison for their crimes," Whitaker says.
Mental
health courts, which are part of a nationwide network,
generally rely on volunteer judges, attorneys, mental health specialists and
coordinators to help people with mental illness get mental health care and a
plan to support themselves without crime or substance abuse. Whitaker, who has
participated in his county's mental health court, says the court meets once a
week to discuss each of the 40 to 50 people enrolled, who ultimately leave the
program in a graduation ceremony.
"At
least from my point of view, the mental health court catches a few people that
would otherwise be in prison," says Whitaker. Nonetheless, he adds,
"I still see mentally ill people go to prison here."
Part
of the reason for that, according to psychiatrist Camille LaCroix, who has
served as an expert in Idaho cases involving mental illness, is that the mental
health court typically does not accept violent offenders or people who
committed sex crimes. These people instead end up in prison, where LaCroix says
they receive treatment in an atmosphere that makes progress difficult: "A
prison is not a therapeutic environment. You have been found guilty. You are
being punished."
Having
no insanity defense also affects people with mental illness who don't commit
crimes, LaCroix argues, because it means less money goes into developing mental
health facilities outside of prisons — the typical destination for people found
not guilty by reason of insanity in other states. "The severely mentally
ill end up rotating through jail" in states without insanity defenses, she
says. "If you have the insanity defense, you're then forced to get
appropriate infrastructure."
As of
2012, Idaho had the lowest number of
psychiatrists per capita in the country, and the state has consistently
had one of the highest suicide rates nationally.
The
American Bar Association and the American Civil Liberties Union have partnered
in Idaho to lobby for a law banning the death penalty for the severely mentally
ill. (LaCroix is involved in the initiative.) Kathy Griesmyer, a policy strategist with the
ACLU, says if a law is passed, it could remove up to two of the nine people in
Idaho awaiting the death penalty from death row. But the initiative would not
change the state's lack of an insanity defense.
In 2012,
the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review a case that
would have forced a consideration of whether or not states without an insanity
defense violate the U.S. Constitution. Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor
and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented from the decision.
Cahill
was a defense attorney in the case. Another recent case of his, which involved
mental illness, is being appealed in Idaho. Cahill hopes that case will reach
the U.S. Supreme Court and that the justices will agree to hear it, though he
knows the odds are not in his favor. "I'm being realistic," he says.
"I don't think [the law] is going to change. But if I don't keep fighting
this battle, then it doesn't."
C 2015 Reader Supported News
Donations can be sent
to the Baltimore Nonviolence Center, 325 E. 25th St., Baltimore, MD
21218. Ph: 410-323-1607; Email: mobuszewski [at] verizon.net. Go to http://baltimorenonviolencecenter.blogspot.com/
"The master class
has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles.
The master class has had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject
class has had nothing to gain and everything to lose--especially their
lives." Eugene Victor Debs
No comments:
Post a Comment